The 2.5 is well known everywhere as being not the most fuel efficient motor, the 6.9L your getting is average. Most midsizes with a V6 can get very close to that with much more power. And you mention highway, how is your city? Pretty close to 10L I bet, which sucks.
Good on VW for bringing back the independent suspension, standard Bluetooth, and rear discs to all trims. Seems priced quite well.
I still think it's a mistake for VW to continue to offer the 2.0L here in North America. Sure it gives them the low price. But if somebody doesn't know that much, and just buys a model with the 2.0L, after a few fill ups they will regret it. They will see the poor fuel economy, the lack of power for that size of a car. Then maybe VW won't have a repeat customer...