Another great comparison guys. Keep it up!
It seems to me that this is a pretty underwhelming class as a whole, at least in terms of fuel economy, value, and performance. Maybe the inherent compromises of adding AWD and increased ride height has more drawbacks in a subcompact, compared to larger vehicles? Or possibly that it just hasn't been done properly yet? The upcoming Honda subcompact crossover could hit the sweet spot here...
I get the desire for increased ground clearance (especially right now, with our awful snow-covered roads). But it still seems to me the subcompact or compact hatches these crossovers were based on make more sense (or at least better value proposition) - i.e., Sonic over Trax, Impreza over XV, Accent hatch or Elantra GT over Tuscon, etc. And if you don't want a small hatchback because you REALLY want AWD or more ground clearance, the slightly larger crossovers seem like a far more complete package. But vehicles sales will be the final aribtor, as usual!