Out from the (very) left field:
Mitsubishi RVR GT
Compact, roomy, good-looking (with the right colour and wheels) and loaded in GT trim. Being upgraded to 2.4 litre engine in 2015, good warranty. Women love these things.
As for other options:
Not in the running:
Fiat 500X - so out of the picture it wasn't even thought up in the thread so far
Renegade - made in a Fiat plant in Italy
Candidates:
Crosstrek - best fit, luxo trim available
Encore - great reviews, but does look odd from certain angles
CX-3 - looks great, tiny trunk, details to follow
HR-V - ditto
Trax - actually a bit better-looking than Encore
Q3 - if she sees this, you're in trouble
GLA - a bit pricey
B250 4Matic - a Matrix that won the lottery, roomier and less expensive than platform-mate GLA but lower