Great review, thanks guys. Funny to read that a Toyota trumps a Ford in value. I agree with others, what a world its coming to.
I do like the honesty of the comments in the review ("here's the one we'd buy, though it didn't win"). I'm not a fan of rankings for that reason, each has a different personality (well, they're all pretty similar, let's face it) so each can see what traits work best for them.
The depth of choice is astonishing though, these all look like pretty capable choices. And the B list someone mentioned is probably even better, on average. For those in the market it's a great time to be buying