These are in a weird spot, which is why you're going to see pricing all over the place....Let's not lose sight of the fact that we're talking about a 15 year old entry level sedan, yeah, they're good driving cars, but it is what it is. The market is younger people looking for a cheap/fun beater, or an enthusiast looking for a bargain...If I am an enthusiast looking for spend top dollar, say $15K, there's a long list of more exciting and driver oriented vehicles that you have access to at that price point. In either case, I think the number of buyers for the top of the market examples is pretty thin.
Since it does sound like Sailor's is one of the better examples out there, and based on the comparable in here, I'd list it for $12,500, with really good photos and description and hope for the best. If someone comes along with anything >$10K, take it and call it a win.
The East coast factor may be a help in this case, fewer listed in the market to drag the prices down...In the GTA these are everywhere so plenty to choose from.