I've been driving boats since I was 6, having an island cottage will do that.
Here's the families boats at the moment, not excluding my dad's (parents are separated).
The main boat is a 2002 Four Winns 23'er with a 5.7L Volvo I/O. Nipissing gets pretty rough and there's almost always a chop, so the big boat is a lot more comfortable on the 16 mile crossing. Uses about 50L for the return trip. It's the green one on the right.
The cedar strip is my step dads. The motor is an old two stroke Johnson 50. It scoots along great but doesn't love to hold an idle at the moment. The boat was built by Giesler Boats and is surprisingly good in rough water, as long as you don't mind getting wet or pounding into a chop.
The far boat in the second photo is my 16' tinny with a 30 four stroke on it. I use it for camping or when I'm at the in-laws cottage near Ottawa, this was the first time I've had it to the cottage. You really have to pick your days. It runs great though, it'll do 28mph with just me and 24-25 with two to three people and light gear. It used about 12L to cover the 32 miles, remarkably efficient.
I bought it right at the start of COVID, paid $2500 for the boat, motor and trailer. Seems impossible now. That said, it needed a
ton of work to get it sorted. Had to redo all the wiring, rip out the
casting deck, new trailer tires and the motor (2003 Merc 25 4 stroke) had a bent prop shaft. So I traded in the motor for the 2015 30. It was ~$6000 including the purchase price to get it where it needed to be. Still pretty damn good compared to current prices.
Deep Water boats were only made for a few years, the story goes some engineers from Lund broke our on their own and started the brand. It has a few design differences than a Lund, higher bow, deeper hull, two transom braces. It is actually rated for a 50, which would be insane. It's very sea worthy for it's size and is super easy to tow.