When we bought our Corolla, just a week or two over ten years ago now (wow!) I wasn't all that impressed with the hard plastics in the interior, but we were looking for low operating costs and overall durability. Today, I am so impressed with those interior materials, as they basically look like new. They might not be luxurious, but holy hell are they durable. Those plastics on the console and places usually get all marred up, but not these. The car looks like new with a quick interior cleaning. Very impressive.
Back when they released the 2009 models in early 2008 they lowered the price by a quite substantial amount (close to 10%) and added a lot of safety equipment (ABS became standard, side and curtain bags, etc, etc) and kept their mechanical quality top-notch, so at the time, something had to give. The tactile part of the interior wasn't all that great, but I am glad that despite being kinda hard plastic and mouse-furry, they sure are of high quality. Nice for us long term owners.