I gave it a 2.5 relative to the styling of other minivans. The Honda would get a 4, the Toyota a 3 and the freaky-looking Nissan a 1 for what it's worth. Does that help put it into perspective?
If we're grading on a curve, then the Mazda5 would have to get a 4.5 - even with the swoopy shape. The previous gen Mazda5 would undoubtedly get a full 5 out of 5! I'll give the new Sedona a 3, cuz I can't remember much about how it looks...
The extended family rented a T&C in T.O. over Christmas this year. My feelings are similar to the other posters - lots of stuff/gadgets, but not really a luxurious environment. I'm sure the Pentastar has decent power, but it was hard to tell when loaded with 5 adults + 2 babies, 6 suitcases & assorted bags, and a double frame stroller (still can't believe we got that much crap into one vehicle!) And the thing drove like a boat, but really, spirited driving isn't its raison d'etre...
After a week's travels, I came away with a lot of respect for the vehicle...but like most other minivan shoppers, if it's my own money I'd get all the practicality in a Caravan wrapper for much, much less, and leave the expensive "fluff" in the T&C.