Let's take a step back here and discuss what insurance is so that you can better understand the rates and what car to look for.
An insurance company will sell you a contract for a policy of insurance based on the 'risk' of certain perils occurring. There are several factors involved, including (but not limited to, and in no particular order):
1. Driver's age
2. Where the car will be driven (i.e. where do you live? will you be driving to work?)
3. How much the car will be driven annually
4. What type of car it is (sporty? More likely to be driven faster. Old/weak? The opposite)
5. What type of anti-theft technology does the car have (the more, the cheaper)
6. Will you have winter tires (some insurers are providing discounts)
7. Will your insurance be bundled with any other policies with the same company (home, auto, etc)
8. What coverage do you want? Some (third party liability) are mandatory, some are optional (portions of the property damage coverage). I'm biased but believe in more than the mandatory minimum.
9. Is the car new vs old (newer/more expensive cars will be more expensive to replace - so you have a higher premium for it).
10. Previous accidents/prior driving history - If you're 'just' getting your licence, you'll be viewed as a new driver and your rates will be higher, though you won't have any accidents presumably.
I'm not a broker so I can't give you an accurate 'estimate', but as others have stated, your chosen vehicle will not be the cheapest to insure - with that being said, it'll be a few hundred more per year over something else you don't want to drive.
With that being said, I always recommend NOT buying ANY car unless you absolutely need one. You sound young and excited to get your licence, but you shouldn't get a car "just because". $9,000 to a young'n is a lot of money - save it up or use it somewhere else. Cars are money pits. Do you have $3,000-4,000 more per year for insurance, gas, maintenance?
