I think this review is absolutely fitting for the Yaris - great job, Peter!
This new Yaris has 'some' excitement injected into it; its fascia and interior have character now, and I think pricing is spot-on. Fuel economy remains a sore spot, but your as-tested numbers are reasonable (assuming we totally ignore that Ford builds the Fiesta, Kia builds the Rio, and Hyundai builds the Accent...). I always abhorred getting a Yaris as a rental car when I rented weekly (always preferring the Fiesta or Rio - I only had an accent once, hated the Mazda2, Fiat 500, and Versa, and the Micra was not yet built), but this would seem less off-putting to me. It's still an economy car, but finally priced as one. Even though materials inside are better, as you describe, the design still screams "cheap" to me, though. The long, slender, boring shifter, the neanderthal-forehead-like dashboard, and the lack of audio-controls on the steering wheel - the latter of which being a sore spot for me on the safety-front. I'm really a proponent of those controls being mandated given that we have distracted-driving laws and radios are still allowed. I hate that my Corolla doesn't have them
I don't care how many 'cogs' the transmission has, but I would like to see highway fuel economy improve. Power delivery is fine, I found.