buying trends do amaze me - how one can test drive an Equinox back-to-back with pretty much any of its competition and still come out ahead for sales is beyond me...
Actually, it's not. Jeff hit the nail on the head with reference to the extensive dealer network. It makes a big, big difference when it comes to availability.
I just got back from a weekend in upstate NY (the first of pretty much every weekend) where literally every other car was a Subaru Forester (the other half were Legacies, Outbacks, Imprezas, and a ton of Priuses
). When I drove around town, the prominent dealership is the Subaru. My brother, who recently moved to Sault Ste Marie wanted a Crosstrek, but was hesitant to buy one because the closest dealership was 3 hours away in Sudbury. He still bought it, but that's because he lived in Toronto, bought it here, and drove it out there. Had he been from the Soo, he wouldn't have driven 3 hrs away to buy a Subaru - and hence why his is the only Subaru he's seen there (shame he didn't get the Tangarine colour).
My father and I also debated marketing today on the commute to work - I noted that every other car was a Forester down there, and he said "well, had I known they were so good in the snow, I would have bought an Impreza instead of a Corolla." I said, "well, sh!t, dad, do you live in a bubble?"
...but maybe I'm the one that lives in a bubble. Marketing matters, availability matters, and sales show it. Especially for rural areas or smaller cities, having no dealership means no sales for many.