Nice review, Jonathan. After reading so many XC60 reviews that heap so much praise on the full-zoot R-design XC60, it's refreshing to read your take on the value - or lack thereof - of the R-design's extra performance. I would tend to agree - how much extra HP and stiff suspension does one really want in a cross-over?
I've been really interested in this car since its debut, and though I vacillate - like any proper car geek - between different possible replacement cars every other week (used A4 Avant, X3, Cayenne, Golf TDI, used 5-series touring, etc., etc.) very few cars seem to fit my needs as well as the XC60, and so it will likely replace my Subaru in a couple of years.
It would seem to be a formidable package, especially as a used value: the unique styling - and I prefer the toned-down, non-R-design trim personally - the class-leading 9-inch ground clearance, the relatively compact dimensions, the 40/20/40 splits seats, the reliability of volvo's tried-and-true T6 engines, the ride and handling; it's the ultimate do-anything car - and used T6's across the border can be found all day long at or below the $30k mark - not bad at all