carcrazy, actually call some places...online quotes are always higher. I have a broker who looks around for me every 2-3 years. I had Johnson's (part of unifund) and now have Chieftain (part of dominion)
Both companies offer 1 accident or ticket forgiveness. My 140 ticket that actually showed up on my record as 3 points and 125KM/H didn't touch my rates at all. In fact, I actually went down a little bit over those three years (26-29 years old).
We now have two cars (2010 WRX, 2008 SX4) and house all fully insured for $293/month