215/50R17 would give you a speedometer error of 1.6% (too slow) according to http://www.miata.net/garage/tirecalc.htmlIn other words, not a big difference at all meaning that it will fit no problems, but given the fact that that tire is going to cost you a bit more over the (correct) OE size, why bother in the first place? I know that wasn't your question, but there it is anyway.