I would like to add that this car would be shared among 4 drivers...my parents, my brother (16), and myself (18..19 soon!).
This means that it has to be automatic (mom...

), and insurance would be an issue. That automatically crosses out the RSX, Civic Si, WRX, etc. etc. That being said, we have NO idea on how much insurance would cost for a tC...
Another option would a be a used 06+ Civic/CSX sedan, but we are just exploring our options right now. So a tC would be more "sporty" than these two, IMO. The tC's price is currently at $20,995...a bit more than a used 06+ Civic, a bit less than a CSX.