Otto Pal, you didn't do a proper sample before making those comments, and then expanding those comments making them excessive. Perhaps its because you just happen to drive this make/model of car in auto form and wanted a total comparison?
An overwhelming percentage of reviews on Cdn. Driver are automatics. I'd guess about 8/9 out of 10, which sounds to me about ballpark for the mix of sales, whatever that is (depending on the category of vehicle).
I have the 2004 coupe with 6 speed manual, and also think its great as a "daily driver". Certainly not a track car, but I don't need that any more. Decent shots of power available for occasional entertainment, if the engine is in the mid range and higher. At lower revs its pretty dull, but adequate and smooth. Handling is "OK" however with this car especially its necessary to dump the OEM tires and get performance radials to be happy.
I'd be a possible candidate for a trade to this car except Honda blew it by making the car too heavy and large, taking it out of my focus. I already think sometimes that the 2004 is too big for me, so this one doesn't quite fit. We also have a 2006 Jetta turbo dsg that is more fun (engine-wise) in normal driving conditions.