Stopped by the Kelowna dealer on the way home for a quick spin/look.
They have 3 used, an X, XS and XT. I did not drive any of these after sitting in the XS. Not enough rear seat room for the family and the pricing seems a bit off for used when compared to the new ones. The XS, which is the trim line I would want for used, was an 07 with about 40,000 km. Priced at $25,000 asking.
So I looked at the 09 X and Touring. No LTD or Turbo available on the lot. Turbo's are in very high demand and they do not expect to have any more for awhile. And LTD is of no interest to me.
The 09 is very nicely built, good solid sounding doors, no tiny, hollow sounds anywhere. Materials on the Touring seem to be pretty decent. Controls seem logical. Much more room in the back half of the vehicle than the older version.
A quick drive in Kelowna traffic shows it to be peppy enough, handles fine but I really need a longer try in it under more varied conditions to make a final call. I noticed National Car Rental has few out of the Prince George airport, so I may try to rent on for one of my business trips in early September. That will be a much better test. And no salesman to be watching over me

Some good news is that they told me Pathfinders are holding their trade in value a bit better than most other SUV's right now, although I still won't get much for it

So overall, I have now eliminated a used Forester and the 09 is looking promising. If I do rent one, I will post more thoughts.