While that is an exaggeration, I'm surprised you aren't looking at a Sienna, given your experiences. Even if it does cost a lot more up-front.
The Sienna would be a NO BRAINER for us =) Unfortunately our budget is on a constraint at the moment.
Due to crash test ratings, the Caravan is no longer in the running. We are learning towards an Entourage now (base model). If we can negotiate to about 3-4k off MSRP (to ~27k) then we will probably go for this van as it has a 0 down, 0% financing for 60 months promotion right now. This promotion suits our needs, and with the 5-5-5 warranty that Hyundai offers, that offers some peace of mind.
If not, we might fix the Previa (last us another few months...) and wait for another deal, or take the plunge and get the oh-so-good Sienna.
PS: I called Village Chrysler (In Ajax) and spoke to Mike yesterday morning. They have 1 red Canadian Value Package left. He was VERY nice and non pushy, offered to find the one I wanted, in the colour I desired.
I also called the Scarborough location and they had one black one left.
Thanks for all your comments, I will definitely keep you updated!