We have a 2006 Corolla and an 06 Matrix XR, both 5 sp. manual.When we are taking a trip we invariably take the Corolla as the fuel economy is waaaayyyy better, and the wind noise absent even with the Corolla's sunroof feature, oh and the driving position is more comfortable and we don't have to downshift on the hills... on the highway the Matrix is 'pushing a lot of air', at least that is how my wife explains it. I find the Matrix underpowered and tire sensitive, although this latter point may hold true for most new cars with cheap OEM skins. The Matrix can really corner hard with Michelin Hydroedge but lacks the power to... well you know, to ungreen the thing in the corners on a nice warm day. Both CD players suck when the cars are at highway speed. The Matrix cruises at 110/kph and the Corolla at 130/kph+
The Corolla feels lightweight and the Matrix feels substantial. The Corolla shifts much more precisely and with a more direct feel. The Matrix hatch does not open high enough to prevent head injury, the pop open glass window is never used so that $$ could have been used elsewhere... both cars hold a lot with the back seats down but the Matrix folds perfectly flat - so I take her to the beach windsurfing. No reliability problems with either and about 45,000km on both... Our Matrix gets much worse fuel economy than does Corolla - 8litres/100km. travelled (sorry US people..) or about 500km per tank and the Corolla gets 650km.- 700km., depending who is driving and the season.