Sir,
I too had the dilema of chosing a winter tire last fall for my Highlander. After tons of opinions, I selected the scorpions. Had previously used the all season scorpions and was relatively happy with them, but was a bit concerned with the agressive tread pattern on the winters.
Needless concern. they were quieter than the stock A/S Deuellers. I then went into the "wonder how useless they will be in the snow" mode. Well I have not had to call CAA yet, and I did not put a shovel in the trunk.
I can't say that they are better than any other brand, but I am extremely happy with them. Took an 8K trip to Calgary and back to Montreal in the late fall, and it was a piece of cake! Snow, rain, tons of ice in Calgary, and never a bad move.
Going to go looking for summers next for my Pathfinder, and will seriously consider Pirelli along with Toyo and Khumo.