If the lighter silver alloys are the OEM's I like them better too. The dark grey ones look too small on the car, and too fragile IMO. The OEM jobbers look good - just the right heft to them.
Subaru has really improved the look of those Imprezas! Love the front and all else more too - rear roof spoiler, exhaust tip, skirts. Nice stance, and neat how the lower part of the bumper chin spoiler thingie wraps around up into the front wheel arches.
Since recently discovering Impreza is larger inside than I thought it was I do see it as better value. Doesn't come across as upscale one iota to me, but that's not it's mission - it's about practical performance, and a really true honest functional design.