I bought an '03 Ford Escape XLS 4x4. And I love it, so far! Everything works great likes its supposed to and the fuel economy is excellent.
Here's the issue:
I love off-roading. And this thing just doesn't cut it as is. I got myself stuck in snow, for Pete's sake! And 4x4 didn't help at all. There's not enough clearance, and not enough power. The all-season tires don't help either.
I want to do this right, but I cannot afford to do it all at once, so I'd like a plan I can work at bit by bit to get where I want to be within a year and still use it for everyday use in the mean time.
Thanks, all! I'm looking forward to getting back out there!
You have done a good job on summarizing your requirements and expectations. I went through a similar exercise a while back when I needed a 4wd for my work.
I very quickly found out that the car based SUV's like the Escape, Tribute, Forester, CRV, Rav4, etc just do not have the abilities I was looking for. Of all the car based ones, the XTrail seems to have the best off-road manners. It has reasonable ground clearance and the transfer case can be locked in 4wd (high only, no low range). The XTrail is the only car based SUV that I am aware of that has that ability. Being able to lock power to both axles rather than rely on a computer to do it is one of the keys to good off-road ability.
I know this does not help, sorry. You have replaced the tires already, I do not think with the Escape that there is much more that can be done. And do not let the people who say "uni bodies make bad 4wd's" sway you, my Pathfinder (which is what I ended up buying) is uni body and is a very capable off-road vehicle. The Jeep Liberty is also uni body, no one complains about its abilities!
I think your choices are simple but hard:
Keep the Escape and get the beater as suggested.
Sell/trade the Escape for a Pathfinder, 4Runner, Liberty or maybe a XTrail. There are some other choices as well, these are just my favorites. Apparently the Australians are doing amazing things with the XTrail as far as off-road stuff goes so it may be the best option for you.
Tough call, good luck.
If you want more info on the Pathfinder, let me know.