Fall & Winter temps tend to knock anywhere from 5 - 10 MPG off your summer mileage too. Cold air is denser requiring more fuel to burn properly, denser air offers more resistance to the cars forward movement, cold parts & lubricants don't move as easy, winter grade fuels vaporize at lower temperatures and burn with less energy, etc. What your noticing sounds normal to me. My ION is noticably thirstier now then was in the summer, it has a new air filter & fresh winter tires at the proper pressure, and after 20,00kms the ECOTEC is finally broke in. Winter fuel mileage sucks but their is nothing we can do about it.